MEP Ramona Mănescu (EPP) wrote an analysis regarding the killing of Christianity by ISIS and the measures to be urgently taken against the elimination of Christians in Middle East.
We present the content of the MEP’s analysis:
European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) is, for many European citizens, just an abstract concept, “another bureaucratic instrument” of Brussels.
I believe this instrument can do much more, being capable to respond in a direct manner to many of the needs and demands of the European citizens. First, it can bring clear benefits in terms of security and economic opportunities. First it can backup European interests and values, like those concerning the protection of the Christian minority which is under an enormous pressure all over the Southern Neighbourhood.
In the spirit of the recent European Parliament Resolution on the systematic mass murder of religious minorities by the so-called ‘ISIS/Daesh’ it is obvious that we need to use in a more efficient manner the instruments ENP is offering, especially those destined to support the civil society and the minorities. The mentioned Resolution points out a continuous deteriorating situation of the Christians in Middle East, in addition to the Daesh actions targeting the religious minorities and any other group which doesn’t respond to their demands. It is not only about a worsening of the living conditions. There is a continuous and accentuated diminishing presence of this minority which it leads, in a very near future, to a complete elimination.
The overall reality of Middle East shows us that the number of Christians, for the first time in the last two millennia, is in a continuous and accelerated decrease. Except just one situation – Israel, in all the other countries of this area the Christians are slowly disappearing. Since 1910, their proportion diminished from 14% to less than 4%. This situation comes out of multiple causes. The intolerance and violent conflicts are just two of these causes, the most visible ones. Christian minorities, without the needed support, are decimated through physical annihilation, forced conversion or emigration. They are replaced by intolerance, extremism, radicalism and terrorism.
The numbers that confirm the amplitude of this reality are overwhelming. In Iraq, the number of Christians dropped since 2003 till today from 1.5 million to just 300.000. In Syria, in just 5 years, Christian minority decreased by 64%. In places which are symbols of Christianity, like the city of Bethlehem, which is now under Palestinian Authority rule, in just two decades, Christians diminished from 66% to less than 20%.
The disappearance of the Christians is caused not only by the conflicts that are troubling the whole area. Islamic fundamentalism and a juridical system inspired by sharia law are contributing to this. The Constitution elaborated by the Palestinian Authority doesn’t protect the land ownership of Christians and is discriminatory in domains like education, culture and taxation. The arson of St Charbel Monastery from Bethlehem, in September 2015, was linked to an electrical short-circuit albeit the building was disconnected from the power. In Iran, Christian Pastor Matthias Haghnejad, Deacon Silas Rabbani, and Pastor Behnam Irani were accused of Mofsed-e-filarz (spreading corruption on earth) and the two pastors were also accused of Moharebeh (enmity against God), crimes which both carry the possibility of a death sentence according to Iranian law. Since the Iranian Revolution of 1979, this charge was widely used to eliminate political opponents. In Egypt, after the Arab Spring, both the Coptic minority and its churches have been repeatedly and violently attacked. We all have fresh in our memory the horrible images of the 21 Egyptians, members of this minority, being kidnapped and beheaded by Daesh.
It is hard to conceive a Middle East stripped by its ethnical and religious minorities which lived here together for millennia, defining its multi-ethnic and multi-religious character. Europe defines itself through its Christian roots, traditions and values. Its history over poses the one of Christianity. Going further, Christianity spread itself starting with the holy places of Middle East.
For the Christians of Middle East, in today’s situation, the words of Martin Luther King have a special meaning: „In the end we will remember not the words of our enemies but the silence of our friends.„
Considering that the ENP is built in such a way to offer flexibility, both for its financing mechanisms and ways of intervention, maybe is not too late for EEAS to look for those examples of good practices and try to replicate them.
It is known that working with state authorities and political instruments takes time and the results are coming after long periods of time. Still, considering that the Christian minority is facing extinction over all Middle East in terms of years not decades, we must use more those ways which are offering faster results, like helping civil society and supporting local communities.
The ENP must also be capable to distinguish between local particularities. Minorities and vulnerable groups, even living in the same areas, have different needs. For example, those with low incomes need economic opportunities while a religious minority, like the Christian one, needs recognition, equal rights and real protection (not just a declared one) from an Islamic fundamentalism in full expansion.
I consider that following the success stories can be a good starting point. For example we can look at the situation of Christians in Israel who represent the only case when the Christian minority increased and not diminished. What functioned in Israel can be extended in the near vicinity, in the territories under Palestinian Authority rule.
The law framework is a key factor. Also, we must look closely to the real institutional practices which can differ a lot from what is written in the law. This is the case of the countries where the secular state lost its power in front of the religious influence. Another element is represented by the help offered to civil society and civic groups. In working with such communities a lot of flexibility is needed. Such flexibility doesn’t mean a lack of transparency or responsibility. Both transparency and responsibility are a must if we want to have a minimal warranty over the proper use of funds. We must not forget that in those places where the control mechanisms are lacking, just transparency and responsibility can offer confidence that the money are ending up to serve good causes and what they were meant for.
The money coming from the European tax payers, which are spent over programs of regional development, for interconnecting transport networks or for environment needs are producing visible and touchable results. A new school, a multi-modal transport hub or a waste water treatment plant are easy to understand accomplishments. The rules used in spending these money are very strict and clear and the competition over the funds is a strong one.
When the same money are spend within the ENP, the results are not so evident and they also don’t come so quick. This doesn’t mean that the financial mechanism offered by the ENP are useless. On the contrary! The benefits for the security of the people living in the targeted areas as well as the one of European citizens can be notable. To these are added the benefits of better economic conditions and more peaceful and stable space around Europe. For these reasons, a better understanding of the benefits, more transparency, identifying success stories and responsibility over money spending are key elements that can only help the ENP.






